Set 40423
Halloween Hayride
Retired Mar 2024Retail price$12.99What LEGO charged
Worth now$31.82Based on 7 recent sealed sales
Asking now$51.37Typical price on 16 eBay listings
vs retail+145%Worth more than it cost
Proven performer
Up 145% on its $13 retail price since retiring. Pay under $10 to still make a margin reselling.
How much is LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride worth?
LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride is worth about $31.82 sealed right now, based on 7 recent sealed sales. That's 145% above its $12.99 retail price. It came out in 2020 with 148 pieces and 3 minifigures. It was retired in Mar 2024. Over the last 83 days its typical asking price has risen 14%, from $45.00 to $51.37. We last checked it 5 days ago.
Price history
Value history
Oct 19$5116 listings
- Lowest
- $45
- Highest
- $51
- Change
- +14%
- Asking vs retail
- +295%
26 observations · median asking · rechecked 8× daily
Should you buy it?
Sellers want $51, but it’s actually been going for $32. Offer low.
If you bought it to resell
Sells sealed for$32
Marketplace fees · 15.25%−$5
Payment processing · 2.9% + $0.30−$1
Shipping · est. from 148 pieces−$9
Reaches you$16
Pay no more than$13
For a 30% return at your costs. Change them and every figure on the site follows.
What it actually sold for
Sealed
$32
7 sold in six months · $27–$40Used
$18
3 sold in six monthsSellers are asking 61% more than buyers actually paid. The $51 figure above is a ceiling; this is the floor to negotiate toward.
Completed BrickLink transactions over the last six months. Real sales, not asking prices.
Set details
- Set number
- 40423
- Theme
- Seasonal · Halloween
- Released
- 2020
- Status
- Retired Mar 2024
- Pieces
- 148
- Minifigures
- 3
- Retail price
- $12.99
- Value per piece
- $0.347
- Price confidence
- high · 16 listings
- Last checked
- 5 days ago
Where these numbers come from
eBay16 live listingsThe asking price here — the median of what sellers want right now, $51. Last checked Oct 19.See the listings →BrickLink7 completed salesWhat it actually sold for — $32 across six months of real transactions. Last checked Oct 22.Open the price guide →Catalogue148 piecesPiece counts, minifigures, release year and retail price come from Rebrickable and Brickset. Retail was $13.See the catalogue entry →
eBay links are affiliate links — if you buy after clicking, we earn a small commission at no cost to you, and that is what pays for the site. BrickLink has no such programme, so those are plain links. Neither changes what we show or what we say about it.
How to read this. The value is the median of live sealed listings, after removing instructions, empty boxes, used sets, multi-set lots and implausible outliers. Real sale prices usually land below asking, so the buy-below figure is deliberately the conservative end of the range.
More Seasonal sets from around 2020
See all →
▲ 113% vs retailRetired40424 · 2020Winter Snowball FightSeasonal · 149 pcs$2842 listings · retail $13Holding value
▲ 50% vs retailRetired40426 · 2020Christmas Wreath 2-in-1Seasonal · 510 pcs$6034 listings · retail $40Flat since retirement
Retired40416 · 2020Ice Skating RinkSeasonal · 304 pcs$2945 listingsNo retail price on file
Retired40410 · 2020Charles Dickens TributeSeasonal · 333 pcs$4540 listingsNo retail price on file